A Sunday Essay on Kamala Harris Donald Trump and Socialism, Communism, Capitalism and Democracy

FLORIDA  
Opinion by:  
E. Eugene Webb PhD

With both political campaigns scouting the outer limits of socialism, communism, and democracy, while making wild assertions about their opponents I wanted to spend some time on the realities of these forms of governance and the economy, might be beneficial and help you in your voting decisions.

I began this research with four main questions. Below are the answers to those questions and the references from where those answers came.

1. What are the main ideas of socialism?

Socialist economics starts from the premise that "individuals do not live or work in isolation but live in cooperation with one another. Furthermore, everything that people produce is in some sense a social product, and everyone who contributes to the production of a good is entitled to a share in it.
Socialism – Wikipedia  https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Socialism

2. What are the three main goals of socialism?

What are the three main goals of a socialist economic system? A planned economy, greater equality, and ownership of income-producing property by the state rather than private parties.

Ch.1 Sec. 4 #2-5 pg. 30 Flashcards | Quizlet

3. Is socialism the same as communism?

Socialism and communism are two different ideologies that have similarities in their practices. Communism eliminates private property in the hopes of creating equality. Socialism seeks greater equality by creating more equal distribution of wealth.

Socialism vs. Communism | Overview & Differences - Lesson - Study.com

Study.com https://study.com › academy › communism-vs-socialism

4. Are democracy and socialism the same?

Theoretically and philosophically, socialism itself is democratic, seen as the highest democratic form by its proponents and at one point being the same as democracy. Some argue that socialism implies democracy, and that democratic socialism is a redundant term.
Democratic socialism - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Democratic socialism Search for: Are democracy and socialism the same?

Now let us compare capitalism as the underpinning of a democracy with socialism as the driving force of democracy.

Economic System and Freedom:
Capitalism and socialism, as economic systems, often underpin different forms of governance, including democracy. Here is a comparison of how each system interacts with democratic principles:

1. Capitalism:
1. Emphasizes individual economic freedom. People can own property, start businesses, and engage in trade with minimal government interference. This freedom is seen as a key component of personal liberty and democracy.
2. The market largely determines the allocation of resources, and competition is expected to drive innovation and efficiency.
3. Critics argue that capitalism can lead to economic inequality, which might undermine democratic principles if wealth translates into political power.
2. Socialism:
1. Emphasizes collective ownership and control of resources, aiming to reduce economic inequality. Essential industries and services may be state-owned or heavily regulated.
2. The goal is to ensure that all citizens have access to basic needs like healthcare, education, and housing, which proponents argue is essential for true democratic participation.
3. Critics argue that socialism can limit individual economic freedom, and that excessive state control might stifle innovation and efficiency.

Role of Government:

3. Capitalism:
1. The government's role is limited, primarily to enforce contracts, protect property rights, and maintain the rule of law.
2. Democratic governance in a capitalist system often focuses on protecting individual rights and freedoms, including economic freedoms.
4. Socialism:
1. The government plays a significant role in planning and directing the economy to ensure equitable distribution of resources.
2. Democratic governance in a socialist system may focus more on collective decision-making and ensuring that wealth and power are not concentrated in the hands of a few.

Equality and Social Justice:

5. Capitalism:
1. Advocates argue that capitalism, by rewarding hard work and innovation, allows for upward social mobility. However, it often results in significant income and wealth disparities.
2. Critics argue that economic inequality can undermine democracy by creating power imbalances where the wealthy have disproportionate influence.
6. Socialism:
1. Emphasizes economic equality as essential to social justice. By redistributing wealth and providing for collective needs, socialism seeks to reduce disparities that can hinder democratic participation.
2. Critics argue that enforcing equality can lead to a loss of individual incentives, potentially reducing overall economic productivity and personal freedoms.

Democratic Processes:

7. Capitalism:
1. Supports pluralism and competition, both in the market and in politics. Multiple parties and interest groups compete for influence, which can be seen as a healthy part of democratic governance.
2. However, the influence of money in politics is often a concern, as it can lead to unequal representation.
8. Socialism:
1. Advocates often emphasize participatory democracy, where citizens have a more direct role in decision-making, particularly in economic matters.
2. In practice, however, some socialist governments have struggled to maintain democratic processes, leading to centralization of power.

Examples and Variations:

9. Capitalism:
1. Countries like the United States and many Western democracies operate under a capitalist system, with varying degrees of regulation and social safety nets.
2. Variations like social democracy blend capitalism with socialist policies to balance economic freedom with social welfare.
10. Socialism:
1. Democratic socialism, as seen in countries like Sweden and Denmark, combines a commitment to democracy with extensive social welfare programs and government involvement in the economy.
2. Other forms of socialism, such as in former communist states, have often led to authoritarianism, although these are not representative of democratic socialism.

Interaction with Democracy:

11. Capitalism:
1. Capitalism can coexist with democracy, but the relationship is complex. If wealth becomes too concentrated, it can lead to oligarchy, undermining democratic principles.
2. A strong middle class is often seen as essential to maintaining a healthy democracy within a capitalist system.
12. Socialism:
1. Socialism can also coexist with democracy, particularly in forms like social democracy, where democratic processes are used to manage and regulate the economy.
2. However, the centralization of economic control in the state has, in some historical cases, led to a reduction in political freedoms.

Conclusion:

Capitalism and socialism offer different approaches to organizing the economy within a democratic framework. Capitalism prioritizes economic freedom and individual rights, which can lead to innovation and growth but may also result in inequality. 

Socialism emphasizes economic equality and collective welfare, aiming for a more equitable distribution of resources, but it may also limit individual freedoms and economic efficiency.

The choice between these systems, or a blend of both, often reflects a society's values and priorities, particularly regarding freedom, equality, and the role of government. Top of Form

·Bottom of Form

E-mail Doc at mail to: dr.gwebb@yahoo.com or send me a Facebook (E. Eugene Webb) Friend request. Like or share on Facebook, follow me on  X at  @DOC ON THE BAY.